Cadmore media player playing audio Murmur, Systolic: Edward Etchells, MD, discusses the clinical examination for systolic murmurs.
Audio Player
Accessibility
Using forms mode, you can utilize keyboard shortcuts to make usability more efficient.
Space bar will play and pause the audio. Pressing escape will close all displays and pressing it again will jump to the end of the player.
You can press A to open the Keyboard Shortcut Dialog which also provides an audio description of the player and all of its features.
Transcript
Result Count
of
Search
Segments
Result Count
of
Search
Name:
Murmur, Systolic: Edward Etchells, MD, discusses the clinical examination for systolic murmurs.
Description:
Murmur, Systolic: Edward Etchells, MD, discusses the clinical examination for systolic murmurs.
Thumbnail URL:
https://cadmoremediastorage.blob.core.windows.net/9af6f406-1968-4810-be90-a0295191263f/thumbnails/9af6f406-1968-4810-be90-a0295191263f.jpg?sv=2019-02-02&sr=c&sig=RvI%2FNLPhkVAGwjjg9khwwGbnc3S%2FIp5URpVoG%2FP8zsc%3D&st=2025-11-04T08%3A54%3A10Z&se=2025-11-04T12%3A59%3A10Z&sp=r
Duration:
T00H16M34S
Embed URL:
https://stream.cadmore.media/player/9af6f406-1968-4810-be90-a0295191263f
Content URL:
https://cadmoreoriginalmedia.blob.core.windows.net/9af6f406-1968-4810-be90-a0295191263f/6830490.mp3?sv=2019-02-02&sr=c&sig=yUzGXENfmM5HNg9MPi01ra0ajq2RlBHYIeSweLAhFek%3D&st=2025-11-04T08%3A54%3A11Z&se=2025-11-04T10%3A59%3A11Z&sp=r
Upload Date:
2022-02-28T00:00:00.0000000
Transcript:
Language: EN.
Segment:0 .
>> I'm Joan Stephenson, Editor of JAMA's Medical News and Perspectives Section. Today, I have the pleasure of speaking with Dr. Edward Etchells about systolic murmurs, a common condition and a topic discussed in Chapter 33 of The Rational Clinical Examination. Dr. Etchells, why don't you introduce yourself to our listeners? >> Hi Joan, thanks for inviting me to speak with you today. My name is Edward Etchells. I'm a staff physician in the Division of General Internal Medicine, at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Center an affiliated teaching hospital with the University of Toronto.
>> Dr. Etchells, what are systolic murmurs, and in what population should systolic murmurs be considered? >> Joan, systolic murmurs are sounds caused during systole by turbulent blood flow, through cardiac structures. They're clinically important because systolic murmurs can occur in any patient at any age. They can be heard in normal, healthy people, but they can also be a sign of clinically important structural cardiac disease. They can also be a sign of other important medical conditions, such as anemia, or thyrotoxicosis, that cause pathologically increased flow through normal cardiac structures.
>> How accurate are cardiologists and emergency physicians at distinguishing abnormal from innocent murmurs? >> So, there are many studies showing that cardiologists are very accurate at both ruling in, and ruling out, clinically important valvular heart disease even though cardiologists are probably faced with far more difficult cases than we would face in primary or secondary practice. I think that's a good demonstration of the principle that practice makes perfect. There is a single study of Emergency Room physicians that also showed very good accuracy.
>> Please describe the steps in the physical examination for assessing systolic murmurs? >> Sure. So, Joan, first, I want to emphasize that it's really important for clinicians to think about the non-auscultatory examination. So, it's not just the listening to the heart with the stethoscope. So, I can't over-emphasize how important it is to look at the JVP, the jugular venous pressure, examine the precordium, and examine the carotid artery pulsation. Once you've decided you're ready to get to the auscultatory or listening part of the exam, take a few moments to be prepared.
So, first, the environment is crucial. It is very difficult to hear heart murmurs in a loud environment. A simple step that I always take is I simply close the door and ask people to not talk while I'm listening to the heart. Next is make sure your equipment is in good working order. I can't tell you how many residents I've seen who have broken or cracked ear tips, which would make it virtually impossible to hear subtle findings, and last, perhaps not for the young people, but for older people like myself, make sure your ears are working, particularly, make sure you don't have a problem with ear wax.
Those are simple steps easily overlooked, worth definitely attending to. Then you are ready to listen, so here are the key steps. First, make sure you know when systole is. The simplest way to do that is to palpate the patient's carotid artery while you're listening to the heart. And the beginning of systole is the first heart sound, which is synchronous with the upstroke of the carotid artery. Next, if the patient is breathing loudly, you may need to take steps to control the breathing, so you can hear what you need to hear.
So one trick is just to ask the patient to take a big breath in, then breathe out, then stop breathing. And, as a clinician, you should stop breathing at the same time you tell the patient to stop breathing, so that you don't forget to tell them to take a breath. That way you can hear things very nicely in between breaths, and you have a few seconds to focus your attention on systole. If you hear any systolic murmur, the next useful step is to decide if there is an audible gap between the end of the murmur and hearing the second heart sound.
If there is an audible gap, this would put you in the category of an ejection type murmur. Then, the last thing I always tell students is, once you've heard the murmur, and done your best to characterize it, forget about it. It's so easy to get overwhelmed or over-excited that you actually heard something. It's actually equally important, or more important to decide what is going on other than the murmur. Focus your attention next on the heart sounds, particularly the intensity of the second heart sound. Look for extra sounds, S4 and S3s.
In particular, spend time listening for diastolic murmurs, because if you hear a diastolic murmur, it completely changes the nature of the case, and mandates an echocardiogram. Finally, you can decide whether you want to do any dynamic maneuvers to decide what happens to the murmur during these maneuvers. A simple maneuver is simply to have the patient go from lying to standing, and the clinician's job is to decide whether the murmur intensity changes as the patient moves from the lying to standing position.
>> What factors determine the precision of the clinical examination for systolic murmurs? >> Joan, I think attention to the steps I just outlined above is critical. A lot of people simply don't take time to make the environment optimal to hear murmurs, and they don't take time to clearly listen to all of the accompanying findings that I outlined above. I also think that there are some simple rules for converting observations into interpretations that can improve precision. For example, if a murmur is not heard immediately, but can be heard with focused attention, that is a grade 1 murmur.
>> What is the reference standard test for determining the cause of a systolic murmur? >> Joan, I think the reference standard is the conventional transthoracic echocardiogram. This is the best, most practical, least-invasive way of detecting clinically important structural heart disease. Obviously, a cardiac MRI or cardiac catheterization would be equally useful, but these are less widely available, or more invasive respectively. >> What are the potential next steps, if a clinician detects a systolic murmur in a patient? >> So, as you recall, the critical distinguishing questions are, is this a normal, healthy person with a so-called innocent systolic murmur?
Is this a sign of structural cardiac disease? Or does this patient have an important, non-cardiac medical condition, like anemia, that is causing pathologically increased flow through normal cardiac structures? So, the first step is to decide whether you're dealing with a healthy person with an innocent murmur. And this is what cardiologists are very good at. There are certain things that really point towards an innocent murmur. So, first of all, the patient should have no red-flag symptoms such as exertional syncope, or angina, or symptoms of heart failure.
Their non-auscultatory examination should be normal, including the precordium, the JVP, and the carotid artery pulsation. They should have normal first and second heart sounds. There should be no extra heart sounds. There absolutely cannot be a diastolic component to the murmur. And virtually all innocent murmurs will reduce in intensity or disappear when the patient stands up. So, these are the types of features that an expert clinician would look for to categorize the murmur accurately as innocent.
If you have these simple tests available, an innocent murmur should be associated with a normal electrocardiogram, and a normal chest x-ray. So, with the physical findings, supported benign or innocent flow murmur, you should still ask yourself, could this patient have a non-cardiac condition causing abnormally increased flow, such as anemia, or thyrotoxicosis? And that's outside of the scope of this discussion. If there is still residual concern after the physical exam that the murmur could represent structural cardiac disease, then get an echo.
>> Dr. Etchells, is there anything else you would like to tell our listeners about systolic murmurs? >> Yeah, I think that four more short messages. First, always listen to your patient's hearts. Second, always take time to document your findings. Third, ask colleagues to verify your findings if you're uncertain of them, and finally, relate your findings to the echocardiograms that you order. The best way to improve auscultatory skills is through practice and feedback. That's how cardiologists get such high accuracy, and it's within the scope of any clinician's practice to do so.
>> Thank you so much Dr. Etchells, for this useful overview of systolic murmurs. Additional information about this topic is available in chapter 33 of The Rational Clinical Examination. This has been Joan Stephenson of JAMA, talking with Dr. Edward Etchells, about systolic murmurs, for JAMAevidence.
Segment:0 .
>> I'm Joan Stephenson, Editor of JAMA's Medical News and Perspectives Section. Today, I have the pleasure of speaking with Dr. Edward Etchells about systolic murmurs, a common condition and a topic discussed in Chapter 33 of The Rational Clinical Examination. Dr. Etchells, why don't you introduce yourself to our listeners? >> Hi Joan, thanks for inviting me to speak with you today. My name is Edward Etchells. I'm a staff physician in the Division of General Internal Medicine, at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Center an affiliated teaching hospital with the University of Toronto.
>> Dr. Etchells, what are systolic murmurs, and in what population should systolic murmurs be considered? >> Joan, systolic murmurs are sounds caused during systole by turbulent blood flow, through cardiac structures. They're clinically important because systolic murmurs can occur in any patient at any age. They can be heard in normal, healthy people, but they can also be a sign of clinically important structural cardiac disease. They can also be a sign of other important medical conditions, such as anemia, or thyrotoxicosis, that cause pathologically increased flow through normal cardiac structures.
>> How accurate are cardiologists and emergency physicians at distinguishing abnormal from innocent murmurs? >> So, there are many studies showing that cardiologists are very accurate at both ruling in, and ruling out, clinically important valvular heart disease even though cardiologists are probably faced with far more difficult cases than we would face in primary or secondary practice. I think that's a good demonstration of the principle that practice makes perfect. There is a single study of Emergency Room physicians that also showed very good accuracy.
>> Please describe the steps in the physical examination for assessing systolic murmurs? >> Sure. So, Joan, first, I want to emphasize that it's really important for clinicians to think about the non-auscultatory examination. So, it's not just the listening to the heart with the stethoscope. So, I can't over-emphasize how important it is to look at the JVP, the jugular venous pressure, examine the precordium, and examine the carotid artery pulsation. Once you've decided you're ready to get to the auscultatory or listening part of the exam, take a few moments to be prepared.
So, first, the environment is crucial. It is very difficult to hear heart murmurs in a loud environment. A simple step that I always take is I simply close the door and ask people to not talk while I'm listening to the heart. Next is make sure your equipment is in good working order. I can't tell you how many residents I've seen who have broken or cracked ear tips, which would make it virtually impossible to hear subtle findings, and last, perhaps not for the young people, but for older people like myself, make sure your ears are working, particularly, make sure you don't have a problem with ear wax.
Those are simple steps easily overlooked, worth definitely attending to. Then you are ready to listen, so here are the key steps. First, make sure you know when systole is. The simplest way to do that is to palpate the patient's carotid artery while you're listening to the heart. And the beginning of systole is the first heart sound, which is synchronous with the upstroke of the carotid artery. Next, if the patient is breathing loudly, you may need to take steps to control the breathing, so you can hear what you need to hear.
So one trick is just to ask the patient to take a big breath in, then breathe out, then stop breathing. And, as a clinician, you should stop breathing at the same time you tell the patient to stop breathing, so that you don't forget to tell them to take a breath. That way you can hear things very nicely in between breaths, and you have a few seconds to focus your attention on systole. If you hear any systolic murmur, the next useful step is to decide if there is an audible gap between the end of the murmur and hearing the second heart sound.
If there is an audible gap, this would put you in the category of an ejection type murmur. Then, the last thing I always tell students is, once you've heard the murmur, and done your best to characterize it, forget about it. It's so easy to get overwhelmed or over-excited that you actually heard something. It's actually equally important, or more important to decide what is going on other than the murmur. Focus your attention next on the heart sounds, particularly the intensity of the second heart sound. Look for extra sounds, S4 and S3s.
In particular, spend time listening for diastolic murmurs, because if you hear a diastolic murmur, it completely changes the nature of the case, and mandates an echocardiogram. Finally, you can decide whether you want to do any dynamic maneuvers to decide what happens to the murmur during these maneuvers. A simple maneuver is simply to have the patient go from lying to standing, and the clinician's job is to decide whether the murmur intensity changes as the patient moves from the lying to standing position.
>> What factors determine the precision of the clinical examination for systolic murmurs? >> Joan, I think attention to the steps I just outlined above is critical. A lot of people simply don't take time to make the environment optimal to hear murmurs, and they don't take time to clearly listen to all of the accompanying findings that I outlined above. I also think that there are some simple rules for converting observations into interpretations that can improve precision. For example, if a murmur is not heard immediately, but can be heard with focused attention, that is a grade 1 murmur.
>> What is the reference standard test for determining the cause of a systolic murmur? >> Joan, I think the reference standard is the conventional transthoracic echocardiogram. This is the best, most practical, least-invasive way of detecting clinically important structural heart disease. Obviously, a cardiac MRI or cardiac catheterization would be equally useful, but these are less widely available, or more invasive respectively. >> What are the potential next steps, if a clinician detects a systolic murmur in a patient? >> So, as you recall, the critical distinguishing questions are, is this a normal, healthy person with a so-called innocent systolic murmur?
Is this a sign of structural cardiac disease? Or does this patient have an important, non-cardiac medical condition, like anemia, that is causing pathologically increased flow through normal cardiac structures? So, the first step is to decide whether you're dealing with a healthy person with an innocent murmur. And this is what cardiologists are very good at. There are certain things that really point towards an innocent murmur. So, first of all, the patient should have no red-flag symptoms such as exertional syncope, or angina, or symptoms of heart failure.
Their non-auscultatory examination should be normal, including the precordium, the JVP, and the carotid artery pulsation. They should have normal first and second heart sounds. There should be no extra heart sounds. There absolutely cannot be a diastolic component to the murmur. And virtually all innocent murmurs will reduce in intensity or disappear when the patient stands up. So, these are the types of features that an expert clinician would look for to categorize the murmur accurately as innocent.
If you have these simple tests available, an innocent murmur should be associated with a normal electrocardiogram, and a normal chest x-ray. So, with the physical findings, supported benign or innocent flow murmur, you should still ask yourself, could this patient have a non-cardiac condition causing abnormally increased flow, such as anemia, or thyrotoxicosis? And that's outside of the scope of this discussion. If there is still residual concern after the physical exam that the murmur could represent structural cardiac disease, then get an echo.
>> Dr. Etchells, is there anything else you would like to tell our listeners about systolic murmurs? >> Yeah, I think that four more short messages. First, always listen to your patient's hearts. Second, always take time to document your findings. Third, ask colleagues to verify your findings if you're uncertain of them, and finally, relate your findings to the echocardiograms that you order. The best way to improve auscultatory skills is through practice and feedback. That's how cardiologists get such high accuracy, and it's within the scope of any clinician's practice to do so.
>> Thank you so much Dr. Etchells, for this useful overview of systolic murmurs. Additional information about this topic is available in chapter 33 of The Rational Clinical Examination. This has been Joan Stephenson of JAMA, talking with Dr. Edward Etchells, about systolic murmurs, for JAMAevidence.
Form Title Download
Media
Transcript
Form Title Bookmark
Entire Media
Segment(s)
Custom Clip
Start At:
End At:
Form Title Share
Entire Media
Segment(s)
Custom Clip
Start At:
End At:
Form Title Accessibility
The cadmore media player is a professional video and audio player experience designed to deliver media as well as relevant transcript, segmentation, and metadata. On the screen is a traditional html audio player with buttons such as play, pause, forward, captioning, language and play speed selection and more. Adjacent to the audio player are generally tabs, one of which shows a scrolling transcript of the audio and the other shows any segmentation of the media, sometimes referred to as chapters. At the top of the audio player is a menu bar containing an Explore button and Tools button. The Explore button allows you to dig deeper into the audio by opening up an explore dialog which contains an about tab which contains rich metadata about the media, a segments tab which contains further information about the audio, and a related tab which contains links to other media related to this media. The tools button opens a menu with options for sharing the media on social media, creating bookmarking links, creating embed codes for your website, generating citations, and more.
Keyboard Shortcuts
Keyboard shortcuts only work while you are in forms mode. By entering forms mode, you will be able to quickly access portions of the media player with single key commands.
Spacebar: Play/Pause Toggle
E: Explore Menu,
O: Tools Menu
T: Transcript Tab,
S: Segments Tab
F: Forward 15,
R: Rewind 15
L: Languages,
P: Playspeed
M: Mute Toggle,
V: Volume Bar
N: Video Only Toggle,
B: Full Screen Toggle
C: Captions Toggle
Escape: Closes dialogs and menus
Z: Next Transcript Chapter
X: Previous Transcript Chapter
Q: Next Transcript Paragraph
W: Previous Transcript Paragraph
Form Title Embed Media
Entire Media
Segment(s)
Custom Clip
Start At:
End At:
Embed Size
-
You Size - Responsive
-
We Size - Responsive
-
Picture Overlay Popup
-
400 x 225
-
512 x 288
-
400 x 700
-
768 x 1024
-
1024 x 512
-
1280 x 608
Form Title Cite
No citation provided.
Info
Segments
Related
Thumbnails
Accessibility
Using forms mode, you can utilize keyboard shortcuts to make usability more efficient.
Space bar will play and pause the media.
You can press A to open the Accessibility Dialog.
This describes many other keyboard shortcuts for media controls.
Exit Clip Mode
The video is currently set-up to show just a clip from 0:00 to video end. You have requested to see a portion of the media outside of the clip.
Click OK to switch to the full media or click if you would like to stay inside the clip. You can always go back to the clip with Tools and Clip Mode